On a recent facebook quiz of mine, I asked the question, what political affiliation do I most closely align with? the correct answer to that question was libertarian, but a few who took that quiz reasonably guessed that I was a democrat. This makes a lot of sense given some of the views I have, my hatred of the bush administration, and my intense hatred of Fox News. I made it a point in college to never consider myself a democrat, and this conscious decision has made it especially easy to align myself with libertarians - I don’t feel as if I’m betraying an ideology or party that is my own.
I think the idea of consciously deciding what you are is more important than most people give it credit for. If I were to consider myself a democrat, I’d identify myself in the same way I identify myself as a fan of the Dodgers and Cleveland Browns. I am these things (what I identify myself as) because I choose to believe in them and want to give them my devotion and loyalty (the same applies to adoption) . I know by making this decision I will likely make myself inherently bias, unreasonable, illogical, and prone to prejudice. Sports are the only thing in which I believe such decisions and beliefs are harmless.
Unlike almost everyone I have ever met, I am willing to admit that I am, to a large degree, shaped by my surroundings. Years of living in intensely conservative areas with conservative people has made me more conservative (3 conservative adj in a row!) than I was when I was in high school, and my years in college studying history/religion have made me inherently more religious than I use to be. As long as you can recognize yourself being changed, I don’t really see any problem with this fact. I’m not sure there is much more I hate than people who cannot understand how easily their environment can change the core beliefs that drive their behaviors.
So to put a long introduction to an end, I think being a libertarian makes you a pessimist. True not all libertarians are pessimists, but I would argue that this idea is an integral character trait in the same way that being super conservative requires you have to have a giant ego, and how being super liberal requires you to think your a better person than everyone else who doesn’t try to save the whales, children, forests, old historic buildings, the world, and so on and so on.
I hypothesize that almost no one is born a libertarian, it is a result of years of being jaded by the stupidity and ignorance of pointless political battles and arguments. Two types of libertarians arise, the idiots that believe in no taxes at all, and the ones who aligned with either republicans or democrats at one point and weren’t stupid enough to buy into the crap their parties kept feeding them. But delving deeper into the psychology of it all, I think that libertarians who came from democrat roots are even almost always pessimists because they lack hope. To be a true liberal, I believe you almost have to have a hope that things will get better to stay liberal. Usually they take the steady natural/progressive movement of societies as small victories that will eventually lead to everything being the way they think it should be. This character trait is not required to be conservative, who tend to see the evolution of societal change as a negative, so rather there is a much stronger imperative placed on preservation and defending. The more things change the more conservative they get, see the progression here?
Now to answer the obvious question of “you think being a democrat or republican is an bad decision, isn’t considering yourself a libertarian the same thing?” - the answer to this question is no, because being libertarian in many ways is just a cop out, because basically it is the political affiliation with the most flexibility to pick and choose what you believe in. The fact is that most “libertarians” don’t vote for libertarian candidates because they never have any chance in winning, therefore I could have easily voted for Obama or McCain without ever once thinking “I am going to vote for McCain even though I am democrat” - that qualifier is what I hate, you should never have to use them when it comes to making a decision over political matters.
So ultimately I believe that being a libertarian makes you a pessimistic, non-committal, fence rider who believes that almost everyone is stupid, but is too lazy to put forth any effort into something that requires you to have any faith in your fellow man.
2 months ago